Search
A refined cream-and-oak living room with a limestone fireplace and large windows overlooking a private Minnesota oak woodland in late autumn.

What a New Home Costs in North Oaks Compared With a Resale

"The last single-family lots to be created by North Oaks Company in the City." That is how the North Oaks Company described Red Forest Way South, Phase II, when the City of North Oaks approved its preliminary plan in April 2024. The phase has seventeen lots, ranging from 1.5 acres to more than 3. The developer has shaped this city's housing supply for decades, and that phase was its final round of new single-family lots inside the city limits.

That fact explains a gap buyers see once they compare new homes with resale homes in North Oaks this fall. New construction is priced as a scarce product. On the resale side, fewer homes changed hands over the past year and inventory is higher than it was a year ago. For a buyer, the decision is whether a new single-level home is worth close to twice the resale price per square foot.

A city of about 2,300 homes that sold 93 in a year

The North Oaks Company describes the city as more than 20 neighborhoods, about 2,300 homes and 900 acres of conservation land. According to the Minneapolis Area REALTORS local market update for North Oaks, 93 homes closed in the 12 months through October 2026, down 21.2% from 118 in the prior 12 months. That means roughly one home in 25 changed hands in a year.

When a market moves that slowly, single months can swing hard. October 2026 alone had 8 closings at a median of $1,051,250, with homes taking 26 days to sell. The report itself cautions that one month's activity can look extreme because the sample is so small. The 12-month figures are steadier:

Resale measure, North Oaks 12 months through Oct 2025 12 months through Oct 2026 Change
Closed sales 118 93 -21.2%
New listings 133 116 -12.8%
Median sale price $973,621 $950,000 -2.4%
Price per square foot $277 $289 +4.0%
Days on market until sale 80 73 -8.8%
% of original list price received 96.1% 97.3% +1.2%

The inventory figures matter most for a buyer. At the end of October 2026, North Oaks had 35 homes for sale, compared with 33 a year earlier. Because sales slowed, those 35 homes add up to 4.9 months of supply, up from 3.8 months in October 2025. Fewer sellers listed, but closings fell even faster, so the listings on the market add up to more months of supply. Homes that did sell went under contract a little faster than a year earlier, at 73 days on market against 80.

Over the same 12 months, price per square foot rose 4% while the median sale price fell 2.4%.

New construction has moved to the edges, one lot at a time

North Oaks Company currently markets four places to build or buy new: Spring Farm, Hill Farm Condos, East Preserve and Red Forest Way. None of them adds new homes at the pace a subdivision once did.

The city's Planning Commission records show what new construction looks like now. On September 24, 2026, the commission approved a conditional use permit for grading for a new home at 6 Cherrywood Circle in Red Forest Way, on a 3.56-acre parcel. The builder told the commission the grading was for the foundation and a walkout basement. At its July 30, 2026 meeting, the commission approved a septic variance for a new three-bedroom, 3,000-square-foot house that Zawadski Homes is building at 5 South Long Lake Trail. The North Oaks Company originally sold that lot in 2020, and it changed hands again in 2025 before anyone built on it. In April 2026, a city planning report recommended approving a conditional use permit for grading for a new home on an undeveloped 3.48-acre parcel at 5 Catbird Lane.

East Preserve works the same way. The company lists a single available lot, at 100 Sherwood Road, in a neighborhood where wooded lots average 2 to 3 acres. Most new single-family homes here now go up one owner, one builder and one city permit at a time.

Spring Farm shows what a new home costs here

Spring Farm is the one place in North Oaks where several builders sell finished villa and twin-home products. The North Oaks Company names three preferred builders there: Charles Cudd Co., Pratt Homes and Wooddale Builders. Pratt Homes says only one lot remains for it, at 124 Spring Farm Road. Wooddale Builders lists two available lots and a starting price of $850,000.

The fall 2026 Parade of Homes, held September 11 through October 4, put prices on three Spring Farm Road entries. The price-per-square-foot column below is our division of each listed price by its listed square footage:

Fall 2026 Parade entry, Spring Farm Road Listed price Square feet Price per sq. ft.
Charles Cudd Co., Chestnut model $924,800 2,824 about $327
Pratt Homes, Springfield model $1,195,000 2,031 about $588
Wooddale Builders, 118 Spring Farm Road $1,329,500 2,277 about $584

The Pratt and Cudd entries were listed as ready-to-build or in progress, shown through sales centers rather than open for walk-throughs. The Wooddale home is a 2,277-square-foot patio home with two bedrooms and two baths.

Compare those figures with the resale market. Over the 12 months through October 2026, North Oaks resales averaged $289 a square foot. Two of the three Spring Farm entries were priced at about twice that. A buyer paying roughly $1.2 million for about 2,000 to 2,300 square feet of new villa is paying for more than space. That price covers a brand-new, single-level, low-maintenance format that very few remaining lots in North Oaks can deliver.

Hill Farm Condos fills a different niche. It is a 22-acre condo community surrounded by 300 acres of protected conservancy, with models open Sundays from 12 to 3 and private tours by appointment. For a buyer who wants North Oaks without a large lot to maintain, Hill Farm and Spring Farm are the two new options, and Spring Farm's builder lot counts are already down to single digits.

The company's next neighborhood is outside the city

The North Oaks Company's newest community, Wilkinson Waters, is next to North Oaks but sits in Lino Lakes. It is planned for late 2027 and will include townhomes for sale, apartments for rent, independent senior living, offices and retail. The company points to new I-35E ramps under construction and puts the site about 10 minutes from downtown White Bear Lake.

That project will add new homes to the north metro. It won't add any inside North Oaks. The private roads, trails and woods that come with a North Oaks address stay with the existing housing stock. The North Oaks Home Owners' Association maintains more than 60 miles of road, 30 miles of trails and 500 acres of woods across the city. Our earlier piece on how North Oaks gathers without a Main Street covers what that shared land looks like day to day.

What the gap means for a buyer comparing the two

Taken together, these numbers show a market where new and resale homes are priced on different logic. New construction inside North Oaks is limited by land the developer has finished creating, so builders can price against scarcity. Resale is limited by how often owners decide to leave, and in the 12 months through October 2026 fewer did. Closings fell even faster than listings, and supply rose to 4.9 months.

For a buyer who wants a North Oaks address and can live with an older floor plan, the resale side currently has more choice than it did a year ago, at roughly half the per-square-foot price of the new villas. Sellers still received 97.3% of their original list price over that period, so the added supply shows up as more homes to compare rather than as deep discounts. For a buyer set on new construction, the decision comes down to one of a handful of Spring Farm lots, a Hill Farm condo, or a single wooded lot with a custom builder and a city permit process of its own.

Sellers are in the same market. A North Oaks seller is competing with 34 other resale listings and with new villas down the road that sell a format most existing homes can't match. Our North Oaks luxury listing timeline walks through how to prepare for that.

FAQ

Are new single-family lots still being created in North Oaks? In April 2024, the North Oaks Company described Red Forest Way South, Phase II, a 17-lot phase, as the last single-family lots it would create in the city. New homes are still being built on individual lots, including projects at 6 Cherrywood Circle and 5 South Long Lake Trail that the Planning Commission approved in 2026.

What does a typical North Oaks resale home cost right now? The median sale price was $950,000 over the 12 months through October 2026, down 2.4% from the prior 12 months. October 2026 alone came in at $1,051,250 on 8 sales, a figure the Minneapolis Area REALTORS report flags as subject to small-sample swings.

Is Wilkinson Waters part of North Oaks? No. It is a North Oaks Company project in Lino Lakes, adjacent to North Oaks, planned for late 2027.

If you own a North Oaks home and want to know where it fits between a $289-a-square-foot resale market and new villas listed near $588, White Bear Lake Realty will put your house next to the 12-month North Oaks numbers and show you a net-proceeds estimate before you decide anything. Start with a free home valuation.

Work With Us

We’d love to hear from you! Whether you’re buying, selling, or just exploring your options, we're here to provide answers, insights, and the support you need. Contact us and start planning your next move.

Follow Us on Instagram